More Reviews from

In Mattituck for the day and not being familiar with the area we relied on to choose a restaurant. So happy we chose CJ’s American Grill! Had a wonderful dinner in the most friendly and welcoming atmosphere. The wall of local wines was beautiful to look at and so reasonable at $25 a bottle. Our prime rib dinners were delicious and you just know by the way it tasted and was served that love and pride goes into every dish. Owner Chris took the time to greet and get to know customers and did everything he could to make sure everyone was happy and enjoying themselves. It was so nice meeting you Chris and we will definitely be back. Best of luck with your beautiful restaurant.